Justin Tucker and Harrison Butker are two of the most recognised kickers in modern NFL history. Tucker spent his career with the Baltimore Ravens, establishing himself as one of the league’s most accurate field-goal specialists. Butker has played for the Kansas City Chiefs since 2017 and has helped the team win multiple Super Bowl championships.
When comparing Justin Tucker vs Harrison Butker stats, Tucker leads in career field-goal percentage, total field goals made and extra-point accuracy. Butker, meanwhile, has built an impressive record of his own through consistent performances and success with Kansas City.
Here is a closer look at their career numbers, accuracy, long-distance kicking, achievements and how the two kickers compare.
Justin Tucker vs Harrison Butker Career Stats
The following figures are regular-season career totals through the 2026 season to date, based on the available Pro-Football-Reference records.
| Statistic | Justin Tucker | Harrison Butker |
|---|---|---|
| NFL teams | Baltimore Ravens | Kansas City Chiefs |
| Seasons | 2012–2024 | 2017–2026 |
| Games played | 212 | 143 |
| Field goals made | 417 | 262 |
| Field goals attempted | 468 | 300 |
| Field-goal percentage | 89.1% | 87.3% |
| Extra points made | 524 | 383 |
| Extra points attempted | 532 | 408 |
| Extra-point percentage | 98.5% | 93.9% |
Sources: Pro-Football-Reference career records for Justin Tucker and Harrison Butker.
These numbers show Tucker’s advantage in overall kicking accuracy. He has converted a higher percentage of field-goal attempts and extra points across his NFL regular-season career.
However, Tucker has also played more games and spent more seasons in the league. Career totals should therefore be considered alongside accuracy and the different opportunities each kicker has received.
Who Has the Better Field-Goal Percentage.
Justin Tucker has the better career field-goal percentage.
Tucker has converted 417 of 468 regular-season field-goal attempts, giving him a career accuracy rate of approximately 89.1%. Butker has made 262 of 300 attempts, for approximately 87.3%.
Although the difference is less than two percentage points, it is meaningful over hundreds of attempts. Tucker’s record demonstrates exceptional consistency across a long career.
Butker’s 87.3% career rate is also strong by NFL standards. His numbers show that he has been a reliable scoring option for the Chiefs over multiple seasons.
Who Has Made More Field Goals.
Tucker leads in total field goals made, with 417 compared with Butker’s 262.
The difference reflects both Tucker’s longer career and his ability to convert a high percentage of his attempts. Tucker entered the NFL in 2012, while Butker began his career in 2017.
Field goals are an important measure of a kicker’s scoring contribution, but they are also influenced by a team’s offensive performance. A kicker can only attempt a field goal when the offense creates an opportunity and the coaching staff chooses to take the points.
For that reason, total field goals made should be considered together with attempts, accuracy and games played.
Justin Tucker vs Harrison Butker: Extra-Point Stats
Tucker also leads in extra-point accuracy.
He has made 524 of 532 regular-season extra-point attempts, an accuracy rate of approximately 98.5%. Butker has converted 383 of 408 attempts, giving him a career rate of approximately 93.9%.
Extra points are shorter than most field-goal attempts, but they still require consistency and concentration. A missed extra point can become particularly important in a close game.
Tucker’s near-perfect record in this category is one of the strongest statistical points in his favour. Butker has still converted hundreds of extra points during his career and has contributed significantly to Kansas City’s scoring.
Who Is Better From Long Distance.
Both kickers have demonstrated the ability to make long field goals, but Tucker has a particularly notable reputation for distance and accuracy.
Tucker’s career includes a record-setting 66-yard field goal against the Detroit Lions in September 2021. The kick gave Baltimore a dramatic 19–17 victory as time expired.
That kick remains one of the most memorable moments in NFL kicking history and is a major part of Tucker’s legacy.
Butker has also made long field goals for Kansas City, including kicks from beyond 50 yards. His leg strength has helped the Chiefs score in situations where many teams might struggle to reach field-goal range.
Comparing long-distance ability requires looking at attempts and makes by distance, not simply each player’s longest kick. Weather, stadium conditions and the number of opportunities can all affect those results.
Justin Tucker’s Major NFL Achievements
Tucker’s career achievements include:
- Seven Pro Bowl selections.
- Five first-team All-Pro selections.
- A Super Bowl XLVII championship with the Baltimore Ravens.
- A 66-yard field goal against Detroit in 2021.
- A career regular-season field-goal percentage of approximately 89.1%.
His combination of accuracy, range and consistency established him as one of the most accomplished kickers of his generation.
Tucker’s performance over many seasons made him a dependable option for Baltimore in both routine scoring situations and high-pressure moments.
Harrison Butker’s Major NFL Achievements
Butker has built his reputation through both individual performance and team success with the Kansas City Chiefs.
His career highlights include:
- Multiple Super Bowl championships with Kansas City.
- An outstanding 2023 regular season, when he made 33 of 35 field-goal attempts.
- A 94.3% field-goal percentage in 2023.
- A career regular-season field-goal percentage of approximately 87.3%.
- More than 250 regular-season field goals made.
Butker’s role in Kansas City’s championship seasons has helped make him one of the most recognisable kickers in the NFL.
His career also shows how a reliable kicker can contribute to a successful team by converting opportunities in close games and delivering points when offensive drives stall.
Justin Tucker vs Harrison Butker in the Playoffs
Playoff kicking statistics deserve separate consideration because postseason games carry different pressures and involve a smaller number of attempts.
Historical playoff records through the 2024 season showed Tucker making 20 of 24 field goals, while Butker made 36 of 40 during the same comparison window. That represented approximately 83.3% for Tucker and 90.0% for Butker.
These figures are a historical snapshot rather than a complete updated postseason comparison through 2026. Postseason totals can change as teams qualify for additional playoff games, so readers should check the latest official records before using these figures as current career totals.
Butker’s postseason record is an important part of his case, given Kansas City’s repeated playoff appearances and championship runs. Tucker’s postseason experience also includes a Super Bowl victory with Baltimore.
Who Is the Better NFL Kicker: Justin Tucker or Harrison Butker.
Based on career regular-season accuracy, Tucker has the statistical advantage.
He has a higher field-goal percentage, a higher extra-point percentage and more total field goals made. His record-setting 66-yard kick is another defining achievement.
Butker’s case is strengthened by his success with the Chiefs, his own strong career accuracy and his contributions to multiple Super Bowl-winning teams.
The answer also depends on what a comparison values most. If the main criteria are career accuracy and longevity, Tucker has the stronger numbers. If team championships and postseason contributions are central to the discussion, Butker has a compelling résumé.
Both have established themselves among the leading kickers of their era.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who has the higher career field-goal percentage, Justin Tucker or Harrison Butker.
Justin Tucker leads with approximately 89.1%, compared with Harrison Butker’s approximately 87.3% in the regular season.
How many career field goals has Justin Tucker made
Tucker has made 417 regular-season field goals on 468 attempts, according to the available Pro-Football-Reference career record.
How many career field goals has Harrison Butker made.
Butker has made 262 regular-season field goals on 300 attempts in the available career statistics through the 2026 season to date.
Who has the better extra-point percentage.
Tucker leads, converting approximately 98.5% of his regular-season extra-point attempts. Butker’s career rate is approximately 93.9%.
What is Justin Tucker’s longest field goal
Tucker made a 66-yard field goal against the Detroit Lions in September 2021. The kick secured a 19–17 win for Baltimore.
How many Super Bowls has Harrison Butker won.
Butker has been part of multiple Super Bowl championship teams with the Kansas City Chiefs.
Did Justin Tucker win a Super Bowl.
Yes. Tucker won Super Bowl XLVII with the Baltimore Ravens following the 2012 season.
Final Thoughts
The Justin Tucker vs Harrison Butker stats comparison shows two highly accomplished NFL kickers with different career paths.
Tucker leads in regular-season field-goal accuracy, extra-point accuracy and total field goals made. His 66-yard field goal and long run of consistent performances have cemented his place among the most accomplished kickers in league history.
Butker has combined strong kicking numbers with significant team success in Kansas City, including multiple Super Bowl championships.
Ultimately, Tucker has the statistical edge in career accuracy, while Butker’s championship résumé is an important part of the comparison. Both have played major roles for their teams and built impressive NFL careers.